Met detective ‘predicts’ fatal stabbing areas in London

pCloud Premium
Flowers at the scene Tanesha Melbourne died
Flowers at the scene of Tanesha Melbourne’s death – the teenager was killed in April 2018

A murder detective believes he has found a way of forecasting where deadly knife attacks are likely to take place.

Det Ch Insp John Massey trawled through records of knife crimes in London over a 12-month period and found a link with fatal stabbings the following year.

More than two-thirds of the killings in 2017-18 occurred in neighbourhoods where someone had been attacked with a knife the year before.

The study is believed to be one of the first to show such a clear correlation.

Research, carried out alongside University of Cambridge criminologists, found that during 2016-17 the Metropolitan Police recorded 3,506 assaults with a knife where the location of the attack had been identified.

The stabbings took place in 2,048 of London’s 4,835 local census areas – neighbourhoods with a population of about 1,700, which are smaller than council wards.

The areas of the stabbings were then compared to the known locations of 97 fatal knife attacks in 2017-18.

The data focuses on knife injuries in 2016-17 by council ward

Results showed 67 of the killings – 69% – occurred where there had been at least one stabbing the previous year.

Mr Massey said: “These findings indicate that officers can be deployed in a smaller number of areas in the knowledge that they will have the best chances there to prevent knife-enabled homicides.”

In one area, around Tanfield Avenue in Neasden, there were eight knife attacks in the 12 months to the end of March 2017 – followed by the fatal stabbing in October of that year of 18-year-old Saif Abdul Magid.

Two boys, aged 14, were found guilty of his murder, which police said was the result of a simmering dispute.

Met Police
Saif Abdul Magid was stabbed repeatedly in a Neasden street

Prof Lawrence Sherman, who co-authored the study, said although solely focusing on knife crime hot-spots was not a “panacea” because many killings happened in areas untouched by stabbings, targeting resources made sense.

“If assault data forecasts that a neighbourhood is more likely to experience knife homicide, police commanders might consider everything from closer monitoring of school exclusions to localised use of stop-and-search,” he said.

The map displays killings during 2017-18

But Prof Sherman warned forces needed to improve their data collection processes to distinguish between arrests for carrying or making threats with knives and stabbings.

“The current definition of knife crime is too broad to be useful,” he said.

“Police IT is in urgent need of refinement – instead of just keeping case records for legal uses, the systems should be designed to detect crime patterns for prioritising targets.

“We need to transform IT from electronic filing cabinets into a daily crime forecasting tool,” he said.

The study, published in the Cambridge Journal of Evidence-Based Policing, also found 21% of the 590 fatal stabbings in London over a 10-year period were flagged by police as involving gangs.

The researchers said the figures “contradict a widespread view that knife-enabled homicides are primarily gang-related”, though in 2017-18 the proportion rose to 29%.

Sorry, your browser cannot display this map

In response, Cdr David Musker said the Met was “always open to reviewing and utilising emerging academic research” and that it supported the Met’s own current research.

He added: “Any research that can help inform both the short and long-term response to violence is very welcome.

“We already conduct high-visibility patrols within high-demand areas and hotspots and proactively police high-risk suspects and known offenders as part of our daily policing plans; we also use predictive analytics and mapping to target our patrols and make best use of our resource, prioritising the greatest areas of threat, risk and harm.

“This is something that the Met, and colleagues across the country, have been developing and utilising to great effect for a number of years.”

‘Shift in mindset’

Home Secretary Sajid Javid is due to outline his plans for tackling violent crime in a speech on Monday morning.

Mr Javid is expected to say the “mindset” of government “needs to shift” to combat the issue – and argue for the use of data to improve our understanding of the pathways into and causes of crime.

Re-emphasising his support for a “public health” approach, the home secretary will also say violent offending should be treated like the “outbreak of some virulent disease”.

Detective ‘predicts’ fatal stabbing areas

A murder detective believes he has found a way of forecasting where deadly knife attacks are likely to take place. Det Ch Insp John Massey trawled through records of knife crimes in London over a 12-month period and found a link with fatal stabbings the following year.

pCloud Premium

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.