Brexit: EU Withdrawal bill suffers 15th defeat in Lords

Latest news

    House of Lords
    Image caption Former Labour cabinet minister Lord Smith was among those backing the amendment

    The government has suffered its 15th defeat in the House of Lords over the EU Withdrawal Bill.

    Peers voted by a majority of 50 to say the government should set up a body to maintain EU standards of environmental protection after Brexit.

    Lord Krebs, who instigated the move, argued that while EU rules would be carried over into UK law, environmental principles underpinning them would not.

    Ministers had promised a consultation on the issue but lost by 294 to 244.

    MPs will decide whether to reverse the measure when the bill returns to the House of Commons. Peers are debating the third reading of the Bill, the last chance for them to propose changes to the legislation.

    The cross-party amendment backed by peers is designed to ensure EU environmental principles continue to have a basis in domestic law at the end of the post-Brexit transition period in December 2020.

    It requires the environment secretary to bring forward proposals for primary legislation to create a duty on public authorities to apply these principles, and to establish an independent public body to ensure compliance.

    Lord Krebs, the former chair of the Food Standards Agency, said he was “not satisfied” with the idea of a consultation and wanted guarantees that existing principles will continue to apply and be enforced.

    “We have heard many times that the purpose of the Bill is to ensure that everything is the same the day after Brexit as it was the day before,” he said.

    “Yet for environmental protection things will not be the same. We’re talking about the protection of our air quality, our water quality, rivers, oceans, habitats and biodiversity.”

    Brexit minister Lord Callanan argued the proposed change was “premature” in that it prejudged a period of consultation and would “ultimately be detrimental to the future protection of environmental law”.

    View the original article:

    In the same category are

    Ian Tomlin: Murder charges over Battersea father’s death Image copyright Met Police Image caption Ian Tomlin was described as a "great father"Two men have been charged with murdering a father who was beaten ...
    Khashoggi ‘died after fight’ – Saudis Journalist Jamal Khashoggi died after fight in consulate, initial results of probe suggest - Saudi state TV This breaking news story is being updated ...
    European Rugby Champions Cup: Leicester Tigers 45-27 Scarlets Manu Tuilagi gained 89 metres - more than any other player on the pitch European Rugby Champions Cup Leicester (15) 45 Tries: Wells, Thompson, Kalama...
    Lewis Hamilton top in US GP second practice Listen to final practice and qualifying on sports extra and the BBC Sport website from 18:55 BST on SaturdayLewis Hamilton was fastest in both Friday...
    Russian woman charged with attempted US election meddling Image copyright Getty ImagesThe US government has charged a Russian woman for her role in a Kremlin-backed campaign to influence the US mid-term congr...
    Jamal Khashoggi: Saudi murder suspect had spy training Image copyright EPA Image caption Turkish media released CCTV pictures allegedly showing the Saudi 'hit squad' suspected of Mr Khashoggi's disappearan...

    Leave a comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.