Diving bans: Will retrospective action work?

How Scottish football has punished divers

The Football Association is calling it “successful deception of a match official”.

Back in December, Burnley boss Sean Dyche said he thought retrospective bans would eradicate diving within six months. The players would stop doing it, if it meant risking suspension for the next two games.

From next season, under new rules announced on Thursday, a panel will review footage each Monday looking for cases – but only players who won a penalty or got a player sent off will be punished.

Will it work?

All the links in Encyclopedic.co.uk stories are in RED with a Square and arrow, follow the links if you need to get more information, All our stories have all the links back to the original source, we also have other versions of the story on our website, Search our site using the link to the top left, check them all so you can decide what is the truth or copy and paste some words into google and get even more sources.

Any external stories, features, news feeds, articles or external website content, linked to from within this website (through direct links or RSS feed boxes, etc.) are the absolute, and strict, copyright of the writers, owners or publishers concerned.

Search our Site 


How it works in Scotland

The Scottish Football Association has had the power to retrospectively punish divers since the 2011-12 season.

Over time its rules have evolved. Now it looks not only at incidents involving penalties and red cards but anything that gives a team a “substantial advantage” – such as a free-kick scored from outside the box.

Vincent Lunny was the SFA’s first compliance officer – a key role in deciding which cases warrant action.

He told BBC Radio 5 live “it would be naive to think it had an absolute effect of wiping it out”.

“There are still many cases every year, and there are still many yellow cards for diving,” he added.

Since the start of the 2014-15 season, players in Scotland have also been able to appeal against yellow cards given for simulation.

The first appeal, however, was only lodged the following season and in total there have been eight.

  • Six were upheld and the caution rescinded
  • Two were dismissed by the tribunal
‘Good idea’ – Klopp on bans for diving

Are decisions black and white?

How much of this sounds familiar?

“Silly to leave a foot in.” “Naive defending.” “Entitled to go down there.” “The ref can’t give it if you don’t go down.”

Motherwell’s ex-Celtic and Middlesbrough striker Scott McDonald was shown a yellow card for simulation on Saturday.

He discussed the incident on BBC Scotland’s Sportsound programme on Monday. One potential difficulty in enforcing the new FA rules is that – as he says – decisions are not always cut and dried.

The following is the exchange between McDonald (SM) and journalist Graham Spiers (GS).

SM: “It’s not diving when there is contact, I wasn’t diving.”

GS: “Scott, if I get your argument right, and I’ve heard it from various footballers, the point you’re making is if there is contact, you’re entitled to take advantage of it and go down. is that correct?”

SM: “Yes.”

GS: “Right, some people call that a dive. You don’t need to go down…”

SM: “Let’s get it right though, I’m not dragging my leg out or trying to make contact. Contact has to be made on my movement.”

GS: “You don’t need to go down though do you? But you take advantage of it and you do go down, so let’s be clear about that as well. It’s diving.”

SM: “How is it diving if there is contact?”

GS: “Because you say you take advantage of it. You could stay on your feet.”

SM: “So you slide in on me and you don’t get the ball. I take it past you but you make contact. You want me to stay on my feet at that point. If I can?”

GS: “If it’s very obvious you’re diving…”

SM: (interrupts): “It’s a split-second, it’s not even really a decision. There will be occasions where you know you are not going to get the ball on the other side. If there is fair contact made then you’re well within your rights in the law of the game to take the contact.”

GS: “The nub of it is this strange phrase: ‘I felt I was entitled to go down.’ I find it’s glaringly obvious. Why deny it?”

SM: “But let’s stop denying it – you’re calling me a cheat, Graham, that’s the difference.”

GS: “I’m not calling you a cheat.”

SM: “If you’re saying I dive, that’s calling me a cheat, Graham. Basically that’s what that is – if I’m diving, that’s what you’re saying. People that dive are cheats. Are they not?”

How Scottish football has punished divers

The view from the Premier League

‘Utter rubbish’ – Allardyce on new diving ban

Reaction from Premier League managers has so far been mixed.

Crystal Palace boss Sam Allardyce says the plans are “utter rubbish” and called for video technology and sin-bins instead, while West Brom manager Tony Pulis embraced the idea.

“Every manager and club will say it’s happened to them, but it’s something we want to take out of the game,” Pulis said.

“I’m pleased it’s the way forward. I don’t think there’s any place for it in the game. I would most probably fine the players as well and give the money to charity.”

Swansea manager Paul Clement echoed Allardyce’s comments in saying punishment for diving should come during the game rather than retrospectively.

“It’s not the answer. Video technology and looking at instant replays of major incidents are the steps that need to be taken,” Clement said.

“The problem is if you’re on the end of a potential dive that could cost you points, retrospective action is not going to help you and your team.

“What it can do is potentially help another team as that player could be banned for future fixtures, so I don’t see retrospective bans as the answer.

“Any punishment has to be done there and then.”

‘Good idea’ – Klopp on bans for diving
Leicester defender Robert Huth welcomed the move in this Twitter post

‘It won’t stop it, but it will have an effect’

BBC commentator Roddy Forsyth on BBC Radio 5 live

When the ban came in there were the same objections in Scotland as we are hearing now south of the border.

The ban doesn’t make a complete difference because some players will still do it but it does now have a stigma attached to it. It hasn’t eliminated diving, it never will, but it has reduced it.

Alex Schalk got a penalty for Ross County against Celtic last month, there was no contact in the box. It was amazing to all of us that the referee did not see it but his anger was such that he thought there might have been.

The television replays proved instantly that the player had dived, the penalty was given and they scored it. Schalk got a two-game ban and in the end the goal did not make a difference to Celtic’s unbeaten record. But it might have done.

Then there was Kudus Oyenuga of Morton, who was sent off for a foul on Hibernian’s Jordon Forster, and on the way to the tunnel he had a square-up with Darren McGregor.

View the original article: http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/39969813

The two were face-to-face, Oyenuga went down like he was shot and McGregor was sent off too. Nothing happened to Oyenuga – although McGregor’s red was subsequently reduced to a yellow.

Beware of other sites you have never heard of giving you news, a lot of them are just wanting to feed you multiple popup adverts and malware

Visit us on facebook at https://www.facebook.com/notinthemainstreamnews/
We use all our content under fair use to compare who is Fake and who is not, we do not claim ownership at all, all stories are published by the owners as FREE RSS Feeds.

Othen.bizRegisteredgites.com Giteinfrance.biz – Simonothen.com = Northernsoulers.uk – LaBataille.co.uk

In the same category are

GB discus thrower Roles, 39, dies Philippa Roles was a bronze medallist at the 1997 European Junior ChampionshipsWelsh discus thrower Philippa Roles, who represented Great Britain at ...
Thousands of pounds won on Terry’s 26th-minute substitution John Terry was given a guard of honour as he left the pitchThousands of pounds have been won in bets on Chelsea captain John Terry being substituted ...
British and Irish Lions: James Haskell says excitement on hold until after Premiership final James Haskell will join the Lions squad after playing for Wasps against Exeter in Saturday's Premiership finalEngland flanker James Haskell says his ...
Nicky Hayden: The backyard racer who conquered the world "The idea of growing up to be a world champion, it just seemed so far away," Nicky Hayden 1981-2017From racing his siblings round the backyard as a t...
Watch the goals: Carney stars for Chelsea in this week’s WSL Chelsea's Karen Carney is the star performer in this week's WSL round-up, which also features goals from Birmingham's Rachel Williams and Manchester C...
More Mike Bassett than Antonio Conte – who makes your team of the season? The BBC Sport readers' team of the year 2016-17Chelsea and Tottenham were the two outstanding teams in the Premier League in 2016-17 - and it's no su...
Manchester United v Ajax: ‘Naive’ to expect no trouble in Europa final say police Follow live radio and text commentary of Ajax v Manchester United in the Europa League final on 5 live, the BBC Sport website and mobile appEuropa Le...
‘It makes you a better player’: Stokes wants more England stars in IPL IPL makes you a better player - StokesEngland v South Africa: First one-day internationalVenue: Headingley, Leeds Date: Wednesday 24 May Time: 14:00 ...
David Moyes resigns as Sunderland boss after relegation from Premier League David Moyes took over last July but could not keep Sunderland in the Premier LeagueSunderland manager David Moyes has resigned following the club's r...
Nicky Hayden: Ex-MotoGP champion dies after collision Nicky Hayden won the 2006 Moto GP championship in ValenciaFormer MotoGP champion Nicky Hayden has died aged 35, five days after being involved in a c...
Man City put five past Watford to secure third Aguero scored his 32nd and 33rd goals of the season - his best tally in all competitions for Manchester CityManchester City sealed their place in nex...
Arsenal win over Everton not enough for top four Alexis Sanchez doubled Arsenal's lead with his 23rd league goal of the seasonArsenal missed out on a place in the Champions League for the first time...
Porter stars as Essex hammer Hampshire Essex seamer Jamie Porter returned match figures of 7-45Specsavers County Championship Division One, The Cloudfm County Ground (day three):Essex 360:...
IPL: Mumbai Indians beat Rising Pune Supergiant by one run to win title Mumbai Indians became the first IPL side to win three titles after a dramatic one-run win in HyderabadIndian Premier League final, HyderabadMumbai In...
Chelsea celebrate after lifting Premier League trophy Chelsea players, including outgoing club legend John Terry, celebrate on the Stamford Bridge pitch after beating Sunderland 5-1 and lifting the Premie...
Super League leaders Castleford beat Leeds in Magic Weekend finale Greg Eden is Super League's leading try scorer after 14 games with 17 tries in 2017Betfred Super League - Magic WeekendCastleford Tigers (6) 29Tries:...
Liverpool beat Boro to hold on to fourth place Georginio Wijnaldum's opener was his sixth goal of the season for LiverpoolLiverpool secured their Champions League return as their initial nerves tu...
Celtic beat Hearts to complete historic unbeaten league season Stuart Armstrong scored Celtic's record-beating 106th league goal this seasonChampions Celtic beat Hearts to become the first team to complete a Scot...
Djokovic hires Agassi as coach as he loses Italian Open final to Zverev Andre Agassi with Novak Djokovic after the Serb's 2013 Australian Open winWorld number two Novak Djokovic said Andre Agassi will be his new coach aft...
Arsenal miss out on Champions League as Man City & Liverpool win Georginio Wijnaldum celebrates scoring a brilliant opener for Liverpool at AnfieldArsenal failed to qualify for the Champions League for the first ti...

Special Promotion

Fancy a holiday in rural France ?

Find your ideal holiday accommodation in France, with peace of mind that all our properties are officially registered

Our aim is to provide potential holiday makers with a choice of properties, all of which are officially recognised by the French authorities as holiday lettings.  Every gite and holiday accommodation on our website is registered in France in one of two ways. It is either registered with the local Mayor as a tourism/short stay property or is is registered as a holiday letting business in France and so has a SIRET number. We will not advertise any properties unless we have seen evidence of this. If you want anymore information about this, please do contact us.

Follow us on Twitter 

Dont forget to “Like” us on Facebook

Other Video sections include:  Disclose TV – Twit Podcasts – Coming Soon our own Youtube Channel

We also recommend the excellent “No Agenda Podcast”  with Adam Curry & John C Dvorak

Comment on this story