US recognition of Jerusalem ‘kiss of death’ for peace process

Latest news

    Media playback is unsupported on your device

    Media captionWhy the city of Jerusalem matters

    An expected announcement by President Donald Trump that the US will become the first state to recognise Jerusalem as Israel’s capital has prompted global reaction ranging from concern to alarm.

    Palestinians said it would be a “kiss of death” for the Middle East peace process, but an Israeli minister urged other countries to follow the US lead.

    Mr Trump is likely to confirm the decision in a speech later.

    He will also approve moving the US embassy to Jerusalem, US officials say.

    The transfer of the embassy from Tel Aviv will, however, be delayed because of logistical and security issues, as well as the need to find a location.

    The Palestinians’ representative to the UK, Manuel Hassassian, told the BBC that the changes to US policy on Jerusalem were akin to “a declaration of war” on the Middle East.

    “This is the last straw that will break the camel’s back,” he said. “I don’t mean war in terms of conventional war, I mean war in terms of diplomacy.”

    Media playback is unsupported on your device

    Media captionPalestinian general delegate to UK tells Today Trump’s planned acknowledgement of Jerusalem as capital is ‘declaring war’

    Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has yet to comment officially, but Education Minister Naftali Bennett described it as a “big step towards regional peace” and said other countries should move their embassies too.

    He added that it would force Israel’s “enemies” to accept that Jerusalem would never be divided.

    But Pope Francis called for the “status quo” to be respected. Dialogue would only come through “recognising the rights of all people” in the region, he said.

    And UK Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson said he viewed the reports of what Mr Trump would say “with concern”, echoing comments by France and the European Union.

    Israel has always regarded Jerusalem as its capital, while the Palestinians want East Jerusalem to be the capital of a future Palestinian state.

    In recognising Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, the US becomes the first country to do so since the foundation of Israel in 1948.

    What is so contentious about Jerusalem’s status?

    The issue goes to the heart of Israel’s conflict with the Palestinians, who are backed by the Arab and wider Islamic world.

    The city is home to key religious sites sacred to Judaism, Islam and Christianity, especially in East Jerusalem.

    Israel annexed the sector from Jordan after the 1967 Middle East war and regards the entire city as its indivisible capital.

    According to the 1993 Israel-Palestinian peace accords, its final status is meant to be discussed in the latter stages of talks.

    Israeli sovereignty over Jerusalem has never been recognised internationally and all countries maintain their embassies in Tel Aviv.

    Since 1967, Israel has built a dozen settlements, home to about 200,000 Jews, in East Jerusalem. These are considered illegal under international law, though Israel disputes this.

    In recognising Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, the US could reinforce Israel’s position that settlements in the east are valid Israeli communities.

    What is the US proposing?

    Trump administration officials said recognising Jerusalem as Israel’s capital was an acknowledgment of “historical and current reality” by the US government.

    However, specific boundaries of the city would remain subject to a final status agreement, the officials said. The status of holy sites would not be affected.

    Mr Trump would also direct the state department to begin the process of moving the US embassy to Jerusalem – but this could take several years as it still has to be designed and built and security concerns would need to be addressed.

    He originally promised the move to pro-Israel voters during his campaign for the presidency.

    The US officials added that the president would still sign a regular waiver blocking the embassy’s move from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem until the new building was completed.

    Successive presidents have signed waivers on the grounds of national security for the 1995 Jerusalem Embassy Act, which mandates moving the embassy.

    Mr Trump has vowed to pursue a peace agreement between Israelis and Palestinians, led by his son-in-law and top adviser Jared Kushner.

    An administration official said the new US policy on Jerusalem was not designed to favour Israel in that process.

    What other reaction has there been?

    Image copyright AFP
    Image caption Palestinian protesters burned pictures of Donald Trump on Tuesday
    • Saudi Arabia, an ally of the US, called the new policy “a flagrant provocation to Muslims”
    • Hamas leader Ismail Haniya called for protests this Friday
    • China warned against escalating tensions in the Middle East
    • Jordan’s King Abdullah said the decision would “undermine efforts to resume the peace process”
    • Egypt’s President Abdul Fattah al-Sisi urged Mr Trump “not to complicate the situation in the region”
    • Turkey called for a summit of Muslim countries in December to discuss the developments

    US government employees and their families have been barred from personal travel in Jerusalem’s Old City and the West Bank for security reasons ahead of expected protests.


    No sign it’s a bargaining chip

    Analysis by Barbara Plett-Usher, state department correspondent, BBC News

    By recognising Jerusalem as Israel’s capital President Trump is fulfilling a campaign promise. There is no other obvious reason he is doing this now.

    Administration officials said he would simply be acknowledging reality – that Jerusalem functions as Israel’s capital. They said the decision would not determine final status issues such as boundaries and sovereignty – that is still left to negotiations.

    On other core issues of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Arab and Muslim leaders may be able to work with changes in the US approach but Jerusalem is also holy land, not just a disputed capital.

    Jordan and Saudi Arabia are custodians of Islam’s holy sites and have issued strong warnings that this move could inflame the Muslim world.

    There is also no indication that this is a bargaining chip to advance the peace process: according to the officials, President Trump is not expected to publicly endorse a two-state solution.

    View the original article: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-42250399

    It sounds like the Palestinians will get nothing. Perhaps there is a wider strategy at work but it looks like a workaround so the president can satisfy his pro-Israel voters.

    In the same category are

    Star Wars: The blockbuster made in Borehamwood Image copyright Shutterstock Image caption Tunisia doubled for desert planet Tatooine in the original Star Wars movie, but the bulk of the film was...
    Britain on the verge: Life along the A1 Image copyright Peter Dench Winding across the United Kingdom, the A1 is the longest numbered road in Britain, providing a route between the capital...
    Brexit: Theresa May claims new sense of optimism in talks Image copyright PA Image caption Theresa May attends a Church service in her Maidenhead constituency Theresa May will tell MPs there is a new "sen...
    Mt Hope installed as ‘UK’s highest peak’ Image copyright BAS/Alan Vaughan Image caption Mount Hope is more than twice the height of Ben Nevis in Scotland Britain has a new tallest mountai...
    Who are the poor Americans? Image copyright Getty Images Millions of jobs have been created in the US economy, but many Americans still live in poverty. Who are they?For nearly...
    ‘How a 3am epiphany changed my life’ Image copyright Kikki.K Image caption After a sleepless night worrying about her future, Kristina Karlsson got out of bed at 3am and put her dream...

    Comment on this story