War on plastic may do more harm than good, warns think tank

Latest news

    MangoesImage copyright Getty Images
    Image caption Mangoes wrapped in soft plastic

    A green think tank has warned of the risk of unintended consequences from the wave of concern about plastics.

    The Green Alliance, a parliamentary group, said plastics played a valuable role and couldn’t be simply abolished.

    It wants to transform the notion of a “War on Plastics” into a “War on Plastic Litter”.

    The group – like many environmentalists – gave a grudging welcome to Chancellor Philip Hammond’s call for evidence on taxes on single use plastics.

    But it warned that rejecting all plastic food packaging could prove counter-productive.

    Agriculture is a major source of greenhouse gas emissions, so reducing food waste is vital.

    Well-packed food – perhaps in plastic – helps protect food from damage, so it can actually save on greenhouse gases.

    Finite land

    The other potential area of concern is the substitution of plastics with plant-based materials.

    Forests are already being felled to grow crops to feed the world’s booming demand for meat production and wild land is also disappearing to produce bio-fuels for cars and electricity generation. But there is a finite amount of land.

    The Green Alliance fears that a demand for plastic substitutes could also increase the pressure for deforestation.

    This would, in turn, lead to more greenhouse gases that would warm and acidify the oceans people are anxious to protect.

    Image copyright LEGO
    Image caption Lego has announced its leaves, bushes and trees will now be made with plastic sourced from sugarcane

    The Green Alliance’s Libby Peake told BBC News: “Plastics are clearly a huge problem but we have concerns that legitimate public outrage will lead businesses and governments to rush into the wrong decisions.

    “We must ensure that whatever solutions we design don’t increase emissions, damage world ecosystems or result in more waste.”

    The public backlash against plastics led Lego to announce that in future it will make its toys from plastics derived not from oil, but from sugar cane.

    It won the headline: “Lego goes green one brick at a time”. But the firm confirmed to me that the “eco” bricks would be made from polyethylene – that’s exactly the same chemical compound as plastic derived from oil (which, of course, came from plants millions of years ago).

    The environment-friendly bricks will last just as long and be just as hard when you tread on them in bare feet.

    Marine pollution

    The firm told me: “The bio-based plastic used is produced from renewable sources and it meets the Lego Group’s requirements for play value, quality, safety and durability.”

    Ms Peake said: “Turning plants into plastic in this way means that, at the end of life, it won’t be biodegradable and will have all the potential drawbacks of traditional plastic.

    “In other words, it won’t do anything to solve the crisis of marine pollution.

    “Lego has done everything right to try to sustainably source material for its bio-bricks. But there’s clearly nowhere near enough sugar cane that can be sustainably sourced if other companies want to follow suit.”

    Image copyright Getty Images
    Image caption What should these plastic strawberry punnets be replaced with?

    So where do solutions lie? Green Alliance suggests:

    • Ban products that are unnecessarily made from plastic and likely to be littered, like cotton buds and straws (Scotland has already committed to this)
    • Stop using so many different types of plastic – and ensure that all types used are easily recyclable
    • Develop recycling markets for the materials that remain

    Increasing recycling won’t be economically viable while the price of virgin material oil and gas remains so low, which is why the EU is examining a potential plastics tax and the chancellor has launched his call for evidence on charges for single-use plastics.

    The UK is not alone in its endeavour to reduce plastic marine litter. A series of conferences throughout the year will bring together nations in search of solutions for a problem that threatens the future of the oceans.

    View the original article: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-43383607

    Follow Roger on Twitter

    In the same category are

    World Cup 2018: Essam El-Hadary becomes World Cup’s oldest player Egypt's Essam El-Hadary marks his World Cup debut by becoming the World Cup's oldest ever player at 45 years and 161 days and saving a penalty.MATCH R...
    The people trying not to melt in the UK #heatwave It's been the hottest day of the year so far - and people have been taking to social media to share their feelings about the heat.More than 25,000 peo...
    Andy Murray beats Stan Wawrinka in Eastbourne to win for first time in a year 2018 Nature Valley International on the BBCVenue: Devonshire Park, Eastbourne Dates: 24-30 JuneCoverage: Watch the women's tournament live on BBC Two...
    Temperatures reach 29.4C on the UK’s hottest day of the year Image copyright AFP The UK experienced the hottest weather of the year so far, with temperatures reaching up to 29.4C in London.Forecasters say high...
    CO2 shortage: Coca-Cola pauses production at some plants Image copyright AFP/Getty Images Coca-Cola says it has "temporarily paused" some production because of the shortage of CO2 gas.However, the soft dri...
    Boy, 3, stung 18 times in Burghfield bee attack Image copyright Karen Todd Image caption An apology message was put up after people were stung following the hive move A three-year-old boy was ta...

    Leave a comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.