British spies could be forced to disclose deepest secrets in legal challenge

Latest news

    View the original article:

    A legal challenge brought against British intelligence services aims to shed light on the nature of their most secretive operations.

    Civil rights groups Reprieve and Privacy International want to make public the allegedly highly intrusive activities of the UK’s security agencies by bringing a case before the Investigatory Powers Tribunal.

    Read more

    Spy agencies illegally collected personal data on British citizens for 10 years, judges rule

    The tribunal is responsible for overseeing the activities of the UK’s intelligence agencies, including MI5, MI6 and GCHQ.

    The legal action is concerned with the set of “directions” issued by then-Prime Minister David Cameron, enabling the Intelligence Services Commissioner to supervise highly invasive and covert intelligence activities.

    Two of these directions were subsequently released to the public with certain redactions.

    One document governed interrogation of detainees abroad by UK intelligence personnel, while the other regulated the extensive collection of personal data by British spooks.

    The third direction was only once referred to in public in a separate legal challenge brought by Privacy International, but was redacted in its entirety.

    The action groups are concerned the third direction may cover intelligence activities just as intrusive and controversial as the other two.

    In a pretrial statement, Reprieve director Maya Foa said:

    We know this secret policy hides a large area of covert activity that is at least as serious and intrusive as interrogating detainees overseas and the mass collection of personal data.

    We also know from bitter experience that without basic transparency, British spooks are liable to cross legal and ethical red lines.

    The Prime Minister needs to stop hiding behind this secret Third Direction and have the courage and leadership to tell the British public what her government is up to,” Foa added.

    Both campaign groups argue the intelligence activities covered under the third direction might be contrary to the domestic and international legal obligations of the British government, specifically the Human Rights Act and the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

    Read more

    Exposed: MI5, GCHQ have 15 secret bulk data collection warrants in force

    Their legal claim states that “if the secret activities supervised under the third direction involve lethal operations or detainees at risk of death or serious injuries” then Article 2 of the ECHR, which imposes a positive obligation to protect the right to life, might be breached.

    In fact, the claimants argue that the blanket secrecy surrounding these activities may in itself breach Article 2 of the Convention.

    Total secrecy of the activities and of any mechanisms for investigation is not compatible with the positive obligations under Article 2,” they said.

    Legal officer at Privacy International Millie Graham Wood further argued “it is wrong in principle for there to be an entire area of intelligence activity about which the public knows nothing at all.

    The risks of such secrecy are obvious given that the Commissioners who are supposed to oversee the activity have previously accepted the intelligence agencies’ interpretation of what is legal without question.

    We invite the Prime Minister to publish the third direction — redacted, summarised or gisted as appropriate – to ensure there really is full and open oversight of the intelligence agencies.

    In the same category are

    Hundreds killed and thousands flee as Saudi-led forces bomb Yemeni port to ‘liberate’ it Civilians are fleeing Hodeidah after hundreds were killed in the Saudi-led coalition’s bomb campaign to take the strategic Yemeni port from Houthi reb...
    Man charged with child abuse after five drugged girls found with him in Mississippi cemetery A 20 year-old man faces felony child abuse charges after he was found in a Mississippi cemetery with five underage and drugged girls – two of whom wer...
    Roger Stone’s meeting with man selling ‘dirt on Hillary’ fires up Russiagate It was no less than “a man with a Make America Great Again hat and a viscous Russian accent” who Donald Trump’s former advisor, Roger Stone, met and n...
    Russian embassy beats Uruguay at opening match of ‘DC World Cup’ in Washington (VIDEOS) The international 'DC World Cup' football tournament has kicked off in Washington DC, with the Russian team beating their Uruguayan diplomat colleague...
    9yo girl, elderly man killed as 6.1 quake strikes Japan At least three people have been confirmed killed and more casualties are feared, after a magnitude 6.1 earthquake hit north of Osaka Prefecture in wes...
    ‘Historic’: The reaction to Mexico’s stunning win against world champions Germany WORLD CUP 2018 DAY 4 LIVE #FansEyeView #FootWall 18 Jun, 2018 12:06 Mexico 1-0 Germany: 'Chucky' goal topples reigning champions at raucous Luzhnik...

    Leave a comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.