Exclusive—Fred Campbell: ‘We the People Should Decide Whether’ Google, Facebook Can Censor

Latest news

    Former FCC Wireless Bureau Chief Fred Campbell told Breitbart News in an exclusive interview on Monday that “We the people should decide” whether Google, Facebook, and Twitter can censor and block content.

    Silicon Valley giants Apple, Facebook, YouTube, and Spotify banned Infowars from their platforms on Monday, which has raised concerns about the free state of the Internet.

    In an interview in April, the former Federal Communications Commission (FCC) wireless bureau chief told Breitbart News that the Safe Harbor provision in Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act allows social media giants to censor at will. Internet service providers (ISPs) and edge providers such as Facebook and Google can host or publish other users’ content without being legally liable for their users’ content. Campbell called for the Safe Harbor provision to be repealed, contending that it violates the First Amendment and overrides common law protections against libel and other falsehoods.

    The former FCC executive said on Monday:

    If they want the ability to edit the Internet and take down Alex Jones, then they should not have Section 230 immunity. If they’re acting like a publisher, which is what they’re doing, they’re doing the same sort of editorial decision making that newspapers and other print publications have been doing since immemorial, if they want to do that why are they not subject to the same rules that the print media is subject to?

    “They’re subject to a legislative exception that is a couple decades old, overturning a century of law. If they want to play editor, great, then comply with the laws that all of the others editors comply with and give up your special exemption,” he added.

    The former FCC executive continued, suggesting that could solve the issue of Silicon Valley censorship without regulation by using antitrust action.

    “It’s about holding the largest companies in the world to the same legal antitrust standards that have been applied since the 19th century,” he said. Campbell said:

    Repeal Section 230 and use Antitrust second. It really bothers me that the theory behind Section 230 is that the justification for it is that these online platforms are too big to edit. They won’t’ be able to edit, they won’t be able to track everything, well they certainly have been able to keep track of Infowars. They have just undermined the basis for their exemption from the law.

    Campbell, the director of the tech policy think tank Tech Knowledge, told Breitbart News that he believes that private companies should be able to curate content. However, monopolies such as Google and Facebook should not be able to have so much leeway to censor.

    “I believe that the government should not be regulating private entities’ ability to block content or censor … the First Amendment generally protects a person’s free speech, “Campbell explained. “We the people should decide whether private enterprises can block content, if we don’t, then under what circumstances, and then based on those decisions, apply that decision fairly across the board,” he added.

    View the original article: http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/breitbart/~3/FstginCk9UE/

    Campbell concluded, “However, I also think the law is clear. In cases where the law is there is market power, then the First Amendment does not meet strict scrutiny or the highest standard does not apply. In fact, there can be remedies proposed by government legislation to prevent or open up platforms to prevent blocking, consistent with the First Amendment, because there’s no alternative in the marketplace.”

    In the same category are

    Donald Trump: I Will Only Pay on Elizabeth Warren Bet ‘If I Can Test Her Personally’ President Donald Trump said he would only pay off on a bet to Sen. Elizabeth Warren if he could test her claim of American Indian heritage “personally...
    Bokhari: In ‘The Good Censor,’ Google Admitted to Censorship — And The Media Ignored It Earlier this week, Breitbart News released “The Good Censor,” an 85-page internal company presentation created by Google, explaining in frank terms th...
    Developers explain what Apple must do to turn Apple TV into a successful gaming platform It’s no secret that the Apple TV hasn’t exactly turned into the gaming platform Apple had hoped it would be. Last month, Minecraft developers announc...
    New Apple Music features I hope are added in iOS 13 and macOS 10.15 I’ve been thinking a lot about new Apple Music features that I hope are coming in iOS 13 and macOS 10.14. Earlier this year, I wrote up an Appl...
    Director Larry Charles: Kanye and Trump Would ‘Be Killed By Police’ If They Were Poor Larry Charles, a major Hollywood producer, and director who wrote for Seinfeld, tweeted Saturday that if Donald Trump and Kanye West were poor instead...
    Law enforcement being told not to look at iPhone screens to avoid wasting a Face ID attempt, report says Earlier this month, the first known case of law enforcement requiring a suspect to unlock their phone using Face ID surfaced. Now, Motherboard report...

    Leave a comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.