Arabic AR Chinese (Simplified) ZH-CN English EN French FR German DE Japanese JA Portuguese PT Russian RU Spanish ES Ukrainian UK

Justices Thomas and Gorsuch: Supreme Court Should Take More Second Amendment Cases

Latest news

    WASHINGTON, D.C.—Gun owners were disappointed Monday when the U.S. Supreme Court declined to take perhaps the highest-profile Second Amendment case in the country right now: Peruta v. California.

    Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch share those gun owners’ disappointment, declaring the need for the nation’s highest court to require adherence to its Second Amendment precedents.

    The Supreme Court has only decided two cases on the right to keep and bear arms: D.C. v. Heller and McDonald v. Chicago. Both involved a law-abiding citizen seeking a handgun in his home for personal protection.

    Peruta took a logical next step, involving an elderly law-abiding citizen who wanted the opportunity to carry a handgun when he is outside the home, either concealed or openly. In an opinion written by Reagan conservative Judge Diarmuid O’Scannlain, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the gun owner, but then an 11-judge en banc panel of that court ruled against gun rights. Former Solicitor General Paul Clement petitioned the High Court for review, backed by the National Rifle Association.

    After several weeks of relisting the case, the Supreme Court denied review. Justice Thomas published an opinion dissenting from that denial, joined by Justice Gorsuch.

    “We should have granted certiorari in this case,” Justice Thomas began. “The approach taken by the en banc court is indefensible, and the petition raises important questions that this Court should address. I see no reason to await another case.”

    Justice Thomas continued:

    This Court has already suggested that the Second Amendment protects the right to carry firearms in public in some fashion,” As we explained in Heller, to bear arms means to wear, bear, or carry upon the person or in the clothing or in a pocket, for the purpose of being armed and ready for offensive or defensive action in a case of conflict with another person.

    Referring to the original three-judge opinion, Justice Thomas added:

    The relevant history appears to support this understanding, The panel opinion below pointed to a wealth of cases and secondary sources from England, the founding era, the antebellum period, and Reconstruction, which together strongly suggest that the right to bear arms includes the right to bear arms in public in some manner.

    Several other appeals courts have ruled on this issue of open or concealed carry in public, reaching opposing conclusions. Normally the Supreme Court takes a case to resolve such “circuit splits.”

    “The Court’s decision to deny certiorari in this case reflects a distressing trend: the treatment of the Second Amendment as a disfavored right,” Justice Thomas reasoned. “The Constitution does not rank certain rights above others, and I do not think this Court should impose such a hierarchy by selectively enforcing its preferred rights.”

    Justices Thomas and Gorsuch conclude:

    For those of us who work in marbled halls, guarded constantly by a vigilant and dedicated police force, the guarantees of the Second Amendment might seem antiquated and superfluous. But the Framers made a clear choice: They reserved to all Americans the right to bear arms for self-defense. I do not think we should stand by idly while a State denies its citizens that right, particularly when their very lives may depend on it….

    The case was Peruta v. California, No. 16-894.

    View the original article:

    Ken Klukowski is senior legal editor for Breitbart News. Follow him on Twitter @kenklukowski.

    In the same category are

    Jeanne Ives Concedes Stunningly Close Illinois Primary Race to Bruce Rauner Joel Pollak / Breitbart News by Joel B. Pollak20 Mar 20180 20 Mar, 201820 Mar, 2018 GLEN ELLYN, Illinois — State Rep. Jeanne Ives (R-Wheaton) conced...
    Study: Trump Tariffs May Add 19k Steel and Aluminum Jobs Michael Mathes/AFP/Getty Images by Sean Moran20 Mar 20180 20 Mar, 201820 Mar, 2018 A study conducted by the Coalition for Prosperous America found t...
    Joy Reid: MD School Shooter Would Have Used AR-15 ‘If the NRA Had Its Way’ Screenshot by AWR Hawkins21 Mar 20180 21 Mar, 201821 Mar, 2018 MSNBC correspondent Joy Reid suggested the Great Mills High School shooter would have...
    The Nuclear Option: Limitless Investigation of Trump Was Always the Plan So this is the new standard for electing a president here in America, the greatest living experiment in self-governance. A man can run the gauntlet ag...
    Administration, Bipartisan Interventionist Establishment Kill Aisle-Crossing Effort to Rein In U.S. Military Involvement in Yemen The Senate resolution invoking the War Powers Act to demand the administration seek congressional authorization or withdraw American support from Saud...
    Resource Officer Blaine Gaskill: The Good Guy with a Gun Who Stopped MD High School Shooter The good guy with a gun who stopped the Maryland High School shooter Tuesday was 34-year-old Resource Officer and Deputy First Class Blaine Gaskill. G...

    Leave a comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *