National Geographic: ‘Our coverage was racist’

Latest news

    A collage of National Geographic coversImage copyright SHUTTERSTOCK
    Image caption National Geographic’s first edition was in 1888

    US magazine National Geographic says its past coverage of people around the world was racist.

    It ignored non-white Americans and showed different groups as exotic or savage, propagating “every type of cliché”, editor Susan Goldberg said.

    The magazine’s April edition is dedicated to race and it has asked a historian to look at past issues.

    It decided to re-examine its coverage to mark 50 years since civil rights leader Martin Luther King was murdered.

    “Let’s confront today’s shameful use of racism as a political strategy and prove we are better than this,” Ms Goldberg wrote in an editorial entitled “For Decades, Our Coverage Was Racist”.

    Ms Goldberg said some of the magazine’s archive material left her “speechless”, including a 1916 photo of Australian Aborigines with the caption “South Australian Blackfellows: These savages rank lowest in intelligence of all human beings”.

    Asked to examine its coverage, University of Virginia associate professor John Edwin Mason said National Geographic had served only to reinforce racist attitudes in a magazine with “tremendous authority”.

    He showed that until the 1970s the magazine ignored non-white Americans, only showing them as labourers or domestic staff.

    You may also be interested in:

    Prof Mason also pointed to photos of natives encountering Western technology – creating an “us-and-them” split between “civilized and uncivilized” – and the excessive numbers of photos of Pacific-island women.

    He compared a piece covering apartheid-era South Africa in 1962 – which barely mentions any problems – and a second piece from 1977, which shows opposition to the regime by black leaders.

    “It’s not a perfect article, but it acknowledges the oppression,” Prof Mason wrote.

    Image copyright AFP/Getty
    Image caption The 50th anniversary of Martin Luther King’s assassination will be on 4 April

    But the historian also acknowledged the good work the magazine did even during this period in showing its readers the wider world.

    “It’s possible to say that a magazine can open people’s eyes at the same time it closes them,” he said.

    National Geographic: Key facts

    • The magazine’s first edition came out in September 1888 after formation of non-profit education group, the National Geographic Society
    • Circulation of over six million worldwide, down from 12 million in the late 1980s
    • Originally a text magazine before adopting photo coverage in January 1905 issue
    • 1982 cover altered a photo of the pyramids at Giza, leading to the first digital Photoshop scandal
    • June 1985 cover was the famous green-eyed Afghan Girl – a refugee child in Pakistan
    View the original article: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-43384747

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-43384747

    In the same category are

    Sex, drugs and A&E: 10 charts on how the under-30s use the NHS Image copyright Getty Images Most of us make greatest use of the NHS at the beginning and end of our lives.But although the 18-30s have youth on the...
    Valley lives: Capturing South Wales in the 80s Rhwng 1984 a 1990 bu 10 o ffotograffwyr, yn cynnwys David Bailey a Paul Reas, yn cofnodi bywyd a thirwedd cymoedd y de. Ffotogallery, a sefydlwyd yn 1...
    Brexit: Theresa May vows ‘smooth and orderly’ EU exit Media playback is unsupported on your device Media captionLiam Fox tells Laura Kuenssberg rebels have not changed Brexit stanceTheresa May has welco...
    Iain Stirling: The man behind the Love Island voiceover Image copyright ITV Image caption Iain is the voice of Love Island One of the less obvious attractions of hit TV show Love Island is the voiceover...
    Johnny Marr returns to save us from ourselves Image copyright Getty Images "As far-fetched as it sounds," ponders Johnny Marr, "mankind has been calling out for help to some invisible force in t...
    Ed Sheeran: Travel and ticket warning for Cardiff concerts Image copyright Getty Images Ed Sheeran fans have been told to plan ahead and arrive early for his record-breaking Cardiff concerts amid travel fear...

    Leave a comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.