Reality Check: Has the UK’s devolution settlement been ripped up?

Latest news

    Nicola Sturgeon tweet

    The claim: The UK’s 20-year devolution convention has been “ripped up”.

    Reality Check verdict: Nicola Sturgeon is right to say the convention has, in effect, been “ripped up”, but it is only a convention and there is no legal reason why the UK government cannot ignore the Scottish Parliament over Brexit.

    Scotland’s first minister says the passage of the UK’s key Brexit legislation without the consent of the Scottish Parliament has “ripped up the 20-year-old devolution convention” in the UK. Is she right?

    Ms Sturgeon’s tweet came after the House of Commons spent less than 20 minutes debating the EU Withdrawal Bill’s impact on devolution.

    The SNP said that showed “contempt for Scottish democracy”, with the party’s Westminster leader, Ian Blackford, leading a walk-out of his MPs during Prime Minister’s Questions on Wednesday.

    The row centres on a so-called “power grab”, with the Scottish government accusing Westminster of keeping powers for itself that should go to the Scottish Parliament at Holyrood, after Brexit.

    Rules and regulations

    The UK government says the “temporary” move will allow the same rules and regulations to remain in place across the whole of the UK in 24 key areas, such as agriculture, fisheries and food labelling.

    Months of talks have failed to reach a deal – although the Welsh government dropped its opposition after changes were made that would put a limit on how long the UK government would keep the powers.

    Last month, the Scottish Parliament voted overwhelmingly to refuse consent for the Brexit bill, with the SNP being joined by Labour, the Greens and Liberal Democrat MSPs and only the Conservatives voting against.

    Image copyright PA
    Image caption SNP MPs walked out of the Commons on Wednesday

    The UK government pressed on regardless – so how was it able to do so?

    When the devolved Scottish Parliament was set up in 1999, it was handed control over many policy areas such as health and education that had previously been decided at Westminster.

    However, an agreement signed by the two governments in 2001 stated that “the United Kingdom Parliament retains authority to legislate on any issue, whether devolved or not” and that it was “ultimately for parliament to decide what use to make of that power”.

    It also stated that the UK government “will proceed in accordance with the convention that the UK Parliament would not normally legislate with regard to devolved matters except with the agreement of the devolved legislature”.

    Image caption A protest against the so-called “power grab” was held outside the Scottish Parliament earlier this year

    This agreement was inserted into the Scotland Act in 2016, which was drawn up after the independence referendum two years earlier and confirmed that Westminster “will not normally legislate with regard to devolved matters without the consent of the Scottish Parliament”.

    The word “normally” is, of course, an important caveat that is open to different interpretations – is Brexit “normal”, for example?

    Consent is sought through something known as the Sewel Convention, named after former Labour government minister Lord Sewel, which, in effect, allowed the UK government to ask MSPs for permission to change the law in an area that is devolved to Holyrood.

    Similar conventions apply in both Wales and Northern Ireland.

    Until Brexit came along, the Scottish Parliament had only once before refused to give its consent – over some aspects of the Welfare Reform Bill in 2011, which resulted in the Scottish government introducing its own legislation to resolve the row.

    So Ms Sturgeon is correct to say that pushing through the EU Withdrawal Bill without the consent of the Scottish Parliament means that the long-standing convention has, in effect, been “ripped up”.

    Political fury

    However, as its name suggests, it is merely a convention and there is no legal requirement for the UK government to seek Holyrood’s permission – or to respect its decision if it says “no”.

    This was confirmed by the Supreme Court last year, when it ruled on the case brought by Gina Miller about the triggering of Article 50, which started the Brexit process.

    Judges ruled that the Sewel Convention was not a legally enforceable rule despite being inserted into the Scotland Act.

    This meant that the Scottish Parliament did not have a veto over Article 50 or, by extension, the EU Withdrawal Bill.

    Regardless, ignoring the result of the Scottish Parliament vote was sure to provoke fury from the SNP, with Ms Sturgeon warning that “the decision to act without our consent, and the manner of doing it, will not be forgotten”.

    Read more from Reality Check

    Send us your questions

    Follow us on Twitter

    View the original article: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-44470777

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-44470777

    In the same category are

    Caster Semenya: Olympic champion to challenge ‘unfair’ IAAF testosterone ruling Caster Semenya is a two-time Olympic champion and three-time world championWorld and Olympic 800m champion Caster Semenya is to challenge "unfair" ru...
    Why we fail to switch banks Image copyright Getty Images The numbers tell it all. The Competition and Markets Authority's investigation into the banking industry in 2016 found ...
    Ryanair calls for restricted airport alcohol sales Image copyright PA Image caption A flight from Dublin to Ibiza had to be diverted to Paris on Saturday after three passengers became disruptive Ry...
    Reality Check: The numbers behind the crackdown in Turkey Media playback is unsupported on your device Media captionWho's been affected by Turkey's state of emergency?Almost two years after a failed militar...
    Upskirting row: MP’s office targeted in ‘pants protest’ Image copyright Nigel Nelson Image caption Sir Christopher Chope's Commons office on Monday morning Anger over a Conservative MP's decision to blo...
    John Travolta mob film Gotti gets whacked by critics Image copyright AFP/Getty Images Image caption Travolta plays Gotti, pictured in 1990, at various points in his life and career John Travolta's tr...

    Leave a comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.